TDC Me

Your Say

Together we can achieve more

  • Home
  • Inclusive Council
  • Environment
  • Water
  • Housing
  • Business
  • Transport
  • Dam
  • Contact
  • About
    • Testimonials

Mapua Shed4 Debacle

11/08/2016

mapua shed4 protest

Controversy From Start To Finish

There is very little about the way that this project was managed that inspires confidence in Council. A commercial project that is in direct competition with ratepayers is never a good look.

Did council need to get involved in this kind of endeavour, which is well outside their area of expertise as was shown by a half million dollar blowout on a 1.2 million dollars project?

Questions have to be asked of those charged with oversight of the project. Yes, it appears that reporting was not carried out in a timely manner but surely the people or person in charge of the project should have picked up on this and been asking questions before 500 000 dollars was spent without authorisation.

The Mayor tells us that this is part of their plan to increase revenue and hold rates down. A spend closing in on 2 million dollars is a lot of rates they could have kept down.  What would the difference on rent return have been if the council had constructed a container mall as councillor Greening had suggested? I am thinking it will take a number of years to pay back the difference from their “good investment.”

Mayor Kempthorne said “Ratepayers are not being asked to bear the costs of either the Shed 4 development or the other work that has taken place at the wharf. Income from our commercial activities, including the rents from Shed 4, will be used to repay the loan funding, and income from the sale of a surplus block of land will go towards it as well.”

I may be missing something here, but who owns the “our commercial activities”? It seems that Mayor Kempthorne has been in council too long if he has forgotten that we (the ratepayers) own the commercial activities, and as such, we are bearing the costs of loan funding.  And even if he argues that he meant we are not bearing the funding out of our own personal income, he is not counting the cost of less money available for essential service upgrades and maintenance.

mapua shed4 protest
Photo: Jessie Johnston – Nelson Live

Then, of course, there is the disgrace over the fence. This kind of petty behaviour has been a blight on our council for a number of years. The statistics of the number people who have taken the council to court and won suggest that court agrees.  But there a number of reasons the fence has to be built according to our engineers (rapidly trying to cover everyone’s butt?) says the Mayor.  Again, councillor Greening was the lone voice asking for solutions to the problems without building a fence. A stand over-ruled by the Mayor who said very early on “the fence would go ahead and the council intended to support its tenants’ interests.”

Tenants’ interests or ratepayer interests, which is more important to you this council elections?

We won’t even go into the rest of the debacle over contractors being appointed without tenders sought, which likely cost ratepayers money, and leaves councillors open to allegations of impropriety whether true or not.

Is this the council you want to oversee a dam construction?

Time for a change?

What do you say?

 

Filed Under: Projects, Spending, Your Say Tagged With: impropriety, Mapua shed4, over spend, tdc

Introducing Dean

Dean McNamara Husband, father, and a fourth generation local from rural Tasman. Now acting as your voice on the Tasman District Council (TDC). More about me.

Email Newsletter

Sign up to be informed of important news and upcoming events

Make your voice count

Testimonials

Fantastic Speech

It was great to have your involvement in the dawn blessing of the Mapua Sculpture at the beginning of March. Thank you for the fantastic speech which encapsulated the essence of what the Sculpture Project is all about.

Janet Taylor
Ruby Coast Initiative Trust

You Rock

[Thankyou] for standing up for democracy & the people you represent. In the words of a younger generation “You Rock”!

Beth McCarthy
Takaka

keep sticking it to them

What a great pity there aren’t more councilors like yourself, who stand for council on behalf of the voters, and who remain steadfast in their commitment to being voter representatives and not council mouthpieces

Gary Thorpe
Read more testimonials
  • Testimonial Submission Form

Councillor McNamara: As Reported In The News

  • Latest News
    • Yet Another Unbudgeted Spend
    • Dam Tax Bites Little Guys
    • Freedom Camping Waste
    • No Support For Dam Report
    • Developing Within Boxes
    • Grandstand Funding Folly
    • Population Projections
    • Recycling Lunacy
    • Another Dam Blow Out
    • Councillors Not Qualified Directors
    • Mapua Boat Ramp
    • Pokies Sinking Lid Policy
    • No More Mayoral Casting Vote
    • Votes By Ward
    • Returning as Councillor
  • News From Last Term
    • Signing Off
    • Waste (of) money
    • Port Tarakohe
    • Free Charging Not Free
    • Re Election Candidates
    • NZTA Priorities
    • Mapua Upgrade Begins
    • Another vote Uturn
    • Traffic Woes Government Nos
    • Consult Fairy Tales
    • Capital Stop-Works
    • Kempthorne Quits
    • 20 million not a significant change
    • Over paid Councillor
    • Dam Train Wreck
    • Death Vote For Dam
    • Dam Scarce Water
    • Barbershop Gossip
    • Dam budget blowout
    • Dam Secrets
    • Wakefield Water Supply
    • Kempthorne Casting Votes
    • Mapua Gateway Sculpture
    • Mayor Spends Up Again
    • Mayor has a talk
    • Alleged Propaganda
    • Dam Affodability Questioned
    • Dam Funding Questions
    • Dam Questions
    • Storm Water Priorities
    • Knitting up a storm
    • Old guard take on new committee roles at Tasman District Council

Archives

Share the joy

18
Shares

Why Vote McNamara?

I am MOTIVATED.
I have business EXPERIENCE.
I am fiscally FRUGAL (some say tight!).
I am a born and bred LOCAL - here to stay
I am CONTACTABLE - reach me through this website.
I know together WE CAN DO BETTER.

Tags

budget blowout casting vote cost of the dam council councillor role dam budget dam overruns Dean McNamara Debt decisions Dr Mike Joy Easter Trading fine print free lunch Funding Governance inconsistencies Lies McKee Memorial Reserve P95 performance Pigeon Valley Fire rate affordability Rate increase rates Richard Kempthorne Richmond risks rules scaremongering mayor spending stormwater strategic misrepresentation Takaka grandstand Tasman Tasman District Council tdc TDC propaganda vote vote for change Waimea Community Dam Waimea dam waimea irrigators water water bylaw

Copyright © 2022 · TDCME.nz · Powered by Nz Marketing Systems · Log in

This website is authorized by Dean McNamara 22a Edward Street Wakefield