TDC Me

Your Say

Together we can achieve more

  • Home
  • Inclusive Council
  • Environment
  • Water
  • Housing
  • Business
  • Transport
  • Dam
  • Contact
  • About
    • Testimonials

Waimea Dam

12/08/2019

waimea dam
waimea dam

I often get asked what my position on the Waimea Dam is.

When we were first presented with a model for the Waimea Dam I voted in favour. At that point it was more-or-less a user-pays funding model. As time progressed the funding model shifted to a public subsidisation of what is largely a private irrigation scheme. Not only in the construction costs but also in the forever ongoing running costs (ratepayer responsible for 51% of running costs) As it moved increasingly in that direction, I felt that I could no longer support the funding model.

However, it was not only the funding model that I have concerns over. I was unable to get satisfactory answers to questions I had about the longevity of the dam in relation to the rate of sediment build-up in the reservoir. If we are selling this dam as a 100 year plus solution to our water needs, then I would like to know that it will indeed have 100 years of capacity. I do not have that security of understanding from the information presented to me (or lack thereof).

Another concern is the budget allocated to certain aspects of the construction. I have experience in earthmoving so have some understanding of the mammoth task involved in operations such as clearing the reservoir of vegetation, putting in roads in unstable terrain, and complying with runoff regulations. Without direct access to the contractors to allay my concerns in how they intend to overcome some of these issues, I am suspicious of the amounts allowed for in the current budget.

Waimea Dam P95 guarantee
It can’t possibly go over $83 million dollars we have a P95

Other details we are assured are not an issue such as the lack of bedrock and reservoir wall stability do not line up with anecdotal evidence. The fact that no scientific study has been conducted into the path of the water into the aquifers nor the capacity of flow into the aquifers does not inspire confidence that releasing water into the river is going to solve the over allocation of pumping from the aquifers either. Nor was the fact that I was unable to get decommissioning cost allocation inserted into the Term Sheets, leaving future ratepayers exposed to the entire cost of the dam clean up at some point in the future.

Finally, I found it absurd that the irrigators were in-charge of the dam office during the stages of contractor procurement and final design of the dam when the irrigators had a capped contribution funding model. Whether they are corrupt or not, this situation leaves open a lot of room for accusation should it come to light that the budget is insufficient. It is thrust further into murky waters when Councillors were ruled ineligible for dam directorships (because of conflicted interests) but irrigators were appointed directors (surely a far greater conflict?).

The result of all this left me in a position where I could not support the current model of the Waimea Dam. I think it carries too much risk burden for the benefit to the ratepayer.

However, moving forward it is important to ensure that any cost overruns are not just borne by ratepayers and we make the most of the deal that has been dealt.  The Waimea Dam could be an asset to the Tasman region but the loading of dam related expenses onto the general ratepayer must stop. The ones benefiting the most need to be the ones paying the most.

Filed Under: Dam Tagged With: Dean McNamara, Waimea dam

Water

12/08/2019

Lake Rotoiti

We grew up in Tasman with an abundance of freshwater, but times have changed. We need to get smarter with our water use. Houses need to install rainwater collection tanks, this increases resilience in the community, and it decreases the load on stormwater systems and the waste of freshwater flushed straight out to sea. There are opportunities to improve the way we handle wastewater and greywater, both as individuals and as a district.

Nitrates and other contaminants need to be more carefully managed and monitored in the Tasman region. We cannot keep burying our head in the sand along with all the other rubbish that is being buried out of sight and all the while leaching into our aquifers.

We need to do better at protecting the health of our river water and to stop the leaching of chemicals into our aquifers.  But farmers and gravel extractors are not the only ones to blame as residential streams contain some of the highest levels of contaminants. We all need to clean up our act because Tasman waterways deserve better.

WATER TANKS

During the recent drought, there were a lot of people asking why the Council doesn’t make water tanks mandatory, or that the Council should buy water tanks in bulk and offer them at a subsidised rate.

To any rational person, the concept of each house having its own water tanks seems to be a no brainer. This is what I thought when I moved the motion in a Council meeting that water tanks should be compulsory on new builds – this was before Lower Queen Street had thousands of new homes built.

But the Mayor and his cohorts blocked my move.

There were several reasons thrown up for why would couldn’t make rainwater tanks compulsory. The mayor said it would be too expensive for first home buyers but apparently didn’t that concern him when making rural builds install three 25 thousand litre tanks (with two of those solely dedicated to firefighting storage). Another objection was the lack of space, however, there are many innovative solutions such as under driveways, garages, or in garage walls to overcome the space issue.

Expensive to treat and plumb was another objection for rainwater systems. But a full-blown treated supply integrated into the house is only one option. Water can be recycled into the house for non-potable uses such as washing machines and toilet flushing. The water could be used to wash cars and water gardens or stored for drought situations to increase network resilience.

Rainwater could even just be collected in tanks and released through drip-feed lines. One of the greatest impacts of development has been to drain swamps for agriculture and to channel water into fast-flowing streams. Our urban development channels most rainwater into pipes that head straight out to sea. Anything we can do to both relieve the sudden surge of stormwater into our pipe infrastructure and the exaggerated effect to the estuary must be beneficial. Not to mention any aquifer recharge that might be encouraged through slow–release systems.

The other obvious benefit is that once the full impact of the dam hits the water rates a tank reticulation system will soon pay for itself.

Tasman water is a precious commodity and it deserves a better level of respect. Join the other voters that think we need a Council with more than one last-century-solution for water issues facing the Tasman region.

Vote

Filed Under: Water Tagged With: Dean McNamara, Tasman, water

Tasman Environment

12/08/2019

Tasman environment and climate change

ENVIRONMENT

Tasman is world renown for our stunning landscapes, but we need to encourage smarter use of our environment for a sustainable future so that generations to come can also enjoy the Tasman experience. We all need to step up including Farming, Business, Tourism, and Residential households in the products we use, the way we treat our natural resources, and the flora and fauna we share the planet with.

Tasman environment and climate change

Are you ready to see change in Tasman?

Would you like to see us protect our rapidly disappearing variety of life? Tasman is home to a number of species on the endangered, and critically endangered species list. We can act now save them or we let them slide into extinction.

It sounds like an obvious choice, but it may require taking action that restricts our “rights” as Kiwis. We may have to give up our right to racing along beaches in vehicles or taking our dogs to beaches and letting them roam free. We may have to give up our right to camp anywhere we like whenever we like.

What are the benefits, apart from saving a few birds and bugs or some plants we don’t know the name of anyway?

Tasman is one of the few regions in New Zealand with significant environments of interest that does not capitalize on this opportunity. We have national parks and we have freedom campers. We do not promote Kiwis (the bird) like Rotorua, or Whales like Kaikoura, or Penguins like Oamaru, or the Gannets of Cape Kidnappers. But why don’t we?

Eco-tourism is far more lucrative than allowing freedom camping. The money generated from eco-tourism not only creates work opportunities, it also allows for more work to be done to protect and enhance our endangered species. Is that worth a conversation about maybe giving up some of our “rights”? 

STATE OF CLIMATE EMERGENCY

I do not believe making declarations of emergency is as effective as implementing a strategy of improving how we live. We can do better and we need to do better. Let’s just work together and get it done.

Why, I don’t support a state of emergency.

  1. I absolutely support spending money to reduce our waste to landfill and to protect our endangered flora and fauna. I do not support the generation of endless reports costing huge amounts of money that would be better spent making an actual difference in building a sustainable future.
  2. I do not support the use of emergency in this context. In 2006 Al Gore said we would reach “the point of no return” by 2016 labelling it a “true planetary emergency.”  We have missed the boat according to Al.
    If we keep calling labelling things an emergency that are decades away then what do we call an imminent emergency? It is like all the hi-viz and orange cones on a work site nowadays it all becomes background noise, or like the little boy who cried wolf.
  3. There is also the fact that a “state of emergency” gives the Government of the ability to step in and take control. They may exercise full military lockdown or evacuation (like Wakefield during the recent fire state of emergency) and sequestration of whatever resources and supplies they deem necessary. Be careful what you wish for.
  4. We have soaring rates of youth suicide and one of the reasons quoted is this feeling of despair that we are all doomed. I do not support treating our youth as political pawns to the point they are taking their own lives in despair. When I was a teenager there was the threat of peak oil and then the imminent threat of nuclear holocaust being thrust upon us, fortunately, there wasn’t the internet compounding the issue back then.

What can we do then?

While it is easy to blame agriculture, forestry and other land use for greenhouse gas emissions. And they may be responsible for 23 percent of global greenhouse gas emissions according to the recent IPCC survey.

But food waste is also a major culprit, according to a new report from the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC).

From 2010-2016, global food loss and waste contributed 8-10 percent of total anthropogenic GHG emissions and currently 25-30 percent of total food produced is lost or wasted, says the  IPCC report on climate change and land. 

This is something that we all can do to immediately affect the amount of emissions adding to climate change. It doesn’t require more reports and endless debates at huge expense. Don’t reinvent wheel just take action.

Join other voters for a practical response to Climate Change and Environmental Issues this election.

Filed Under: Environment, Resources Tagged With: Dean McNamara, Tasman environment

Pigeon Valley Fire

15/02/2019

Water tankers filling Wakefield

From the perspective of a Wakefield resident, I can say the Pigeon Valley Fire has been an emotional roller coaster. For those residents of the various valleys most affected one can only begin to imagine the toll that the past week or so has had. While I was evacuated for a few nights the stress was nothing compared to those who have lived (and as I write this, some who continue to live) with the extended uncertainty of the safety of their homes, and the wellbeing of their animals while they remain outside the cordon.

When I first saw the smoke rising up the valley after hearing the sirens, I knew there would be trouble. The vegetation all around was tinder dry and the wind was blowing a stiff southerly. It became apparent very quickly that my initial fears were well founded as the horizon grew black with the thick smoke of a fire out of control.

But from this point the story has two sides. This post will address the experience of working with the various teams and people on the ground. I believe a future post needs to address the experience of working with those removed from the front lines.

When Civil Defence mobilized the Wakefield Centre for evacuated and affected parties, I headed up the street to join the team. This became “home” for the next few days.

From day one there was a steady stream of people coming through offering support for those affected. There were donations of food and supplies, and people offering a place to stay, and homes for animals. The local 4 Square owner thought far enough ahead to provide magazines for people to pass the time with as well the generous food donations. Other local bakeries and businesses were also quick to contribute.

Initially, I got to work alongside Civil Defence staff, and later with Red Cross staff, Police, and the Community Patrol. It was great to see these agencies in action and meet people that had flown and driven in from all around the country to join the local efforts. My role was more one of moral support and a local face to greet people as they came to the centre – and provide some local knowledge when required to the out-of-town staff running the centre. Other locals also helped man the door and, more importantly, the kitchen.

During the quiet moments between evacuations, alarms, and the war-zone like aerial assault noise, I got to hear some interesting personal stories from the people behind the uniforms. Stories of personal struggle and yet an amazing heart to keep serving others. Stories of just joined to stories of long service and other emergencies they had been involved in, such as the Christchurch fire and earthquakes.

Water tankers filling Wakefield
Three water tankers reload before heading back to the front line

Once the Wakefield Civil Defence centre was shut down and operations moved to Saxton Field, I declined the offer to join the team in Richmond and instead went home to prepare to evacuate. I had already told my family to self-evacuate the previous night, which they did that morning (enabling me to focus on helping others without worrying about them).

When you walk into your house with the knowledge that you have only a limited amount of time to pack up and leave it is a daunting prospect as you look at all your “stuff.” What do you take? What is really that important in the greater scheme of things? Do you just pack some clothes and hope the Fire boys and girls are going to stop the monster before it gets to you?

Electing to mostly do the later I headed off in my caravan to try and get some sorely needed sleep. As I drove out I could see other caravans being dragged out from behind houses for the first time in a long time, people loading up trailers and vehicles, and lots of houses already with big crosses painted on showing they had already been cleared. The army and air force were already setting up patrols and cordons with the police which provided some comfort to know that if the fire stayed away no one else would be cleaning out houses left evacuated.

The next day, I got to experience more of the generosity from people from across the district and around the country as I lined up at Saxton Field for a lunch. To see the amount of supplies that had been delivered and the crowd of people surging through the doors I could only admire the volunteers that had stepped up to help man the centre. I am sure none of them realised the mammoth task that lay before them when they first thought it would be good to help assist feeding a few evacuees and firefighters. Things snowballed suddenly when all of Wakefield was evacuated, I am sure.

That night I was fortunate enough to be in the right place at the right time to offer assistance to a crew going in to create the huge fire breaks that appeared within days. Again, these operators worked through the night with barely a pause to give the firefighters a fighting chance to head the fire off despite predicted strong winds (that fortunately did not eventuate). I slept better the following morning after seeing the work that had been accomplished overnight.

Wakefield fire break creation crew
One of the machines working through the night

Monday, I was at a lose end whilst still homeless when I bumped into Marty Price of the Community Patrol (he was wearing his Search and Rescue hat at the time) who suggested I should help the Community Patrol members at the Richmond A&P Show grounds. How could I refuse?

The next few days were then spent helping to manage traffic flows at the show grounds. Thank you to the many who obeyed instructions without the verbal abuse that a few felt the need to express (I know which taxi service I won’t be using, for example).

Again, it was an amazing experience to see the generosity of locals showing up with a few leaves for the rabbits to trucks (and horse floats) rolling in from Blenheim, Murchison, and Canterbury loaded with hay and supplies. There were regular volunteers showing up to assist the amazing team from HUHA from dog walkers to the “poo crew.” There were some very tired looking vets and vet helpers rotating through too (I even got to meet Summer). Federated farmers and farmer support teams also were doing a great job organising the larger animal transfers and feeding assistance, along with emotional health help.

Although traffic duty seemed a little unglamorous compared to those who were dealing with the evacuated animals, there was a lot of praise from the people of those organisations for the Community Patrol (teams from Richmond assisted by teams from Motueka) that I was working along side.  Once the Community Patrol (especially one member who would take no credit) arrived and set up a traffic management plan, food drop points, and only let those who needed to be on site through the gates it enabled the other organisations to focus on doing what they do best – dealing with animals. Things were then able to run a lot smoother.

So, from this perspective, it was an amazing experience to be part of. To see how many selfless people there are in our community and around the country who volunteer countless hours to assist others in times of need.

However, even as the air currently still hums with the sound of aerial firefighters and no doubt ground crews swelter away in the heat somewhere over the ridge, the media has dissipated, and over the coming weeks the fire will (hopefully) get pushed to the back of our minds. But, the groups that stepped up over this time will continue on working away in the background and most of them are struggling for members and support.

So, before you forget how it felt to be a part of something bigger than yourself, I would encourage you to sign up to one of the organisations that you saw in action over the past week or so. Obviously, we are not all cut out to be firefighters (but if you are, give your local station a call and see if they need extra volunteers) but there are many other roles, and even if you can’t spare a little time every month then perhaps you can become a regular financial supporter.

For me, I think I will look at joining the Richmond Community Patrol – expect a call Marty!


Dean McNamara in the media to do with the fire.

  • Wakefield engulfed in smoke
  • State of Emergency Declared
  • School Closure
  • Wakefield Evacuation
  • and even a mention in Parliment

Filed Under: History, Your Say Tagged With: Dean McNamara, Evacuation, Pigeon Valley Fire, Wakefield

« Previous Page

Introducing Dean

Dean McNamara Husband, father, and a fourth generation local from rural Tasman. No longer acting as your voice on the Tasman District Council (TDC). More about me.

Email Newsletter

Sign up to be informed of important news and upcoming events

Make your voice count

Testimonials

Fantastic Speech

It was great to have your involvement in the dawn blessing of the Mapua Sculpture at the beginning of March. Thank you for the fantastic speech which encapsulated the essence of what the Sculpture Project is all about.

Janet Taylor
Ruby Coast Initiative Trust

You Rock

[Thankyou] for standing up for democracy & the people you represent. In the words of a younger generation “You Rock”!

Beth McCarthy
Takaka

keep sticking it to them

What a great pity there aren’t more councilors like yourself, who stand for council on behalf of the voters, and who remain steadfast in their commitment to being voter representatives and not council mouthpieces

Gary Thorpe
Read more testimonials
  • Testimonial Submission Form

Councillor McNamara: As Reported In The News

  • Latest News
    • Yet Another Unbudgeted Spend
    • Dam Tax Bites Little Guys
    • Freedom Camping Waste
    • No Support For Dam Report
    • Developing Within Boxes
    • Grandstand Funding Folly
    • Population Projections
    • Recycling Lunacy
    • Another Dam Blow Out
    • Councillors Not Qualified Directors
    • Mapua Boat Ramp
    • Pokies Sinking Lid Policy
    • No More Mayoral Casting Vote
    • Votes By Ward
    • Returning as Councillor
  • News From Last Term
    • Signing Off
    • Waste (of) money
    • Port Tarakohe
    • Free Charging Not Free
    • Re Election Candidates
    • NZTA Priorities
    • Mapua Upgrade Begins
    • Another vote Uturn
    • Traffic Woes Government Nos
    • Consult Fairy Tales
    • Capital Stop-Works
    • Kempthorne Quits
    • 20 million not a significant change
    • Over paid Councillor
    • Dam Train Wreck
    • Death Vote For Dam
    • Dam Scarce Water
    • Barbershop Gossip
    • Dam budget blowout
    • Dam Secrets
    • Wakefield Water Supply
    • Kempthorne Casting Votes
    • Mapua Gateway Sculpture
    • Mayor Spends Up Again
    • Mayor has a talk
    • Alleged Propaganda
    • Dam Affodability Questioned
    • Dam Funding Questions
    • Dam Questions
    • Storm Water Priorities
    • Knitting up a storm
    • Old guard take on new committee roles at Tasman District Council

Archives

Share the joy

Why Vote McNamara?

I am MOTIVATED.
I have business EXPERIENCE.
I am fiscally FRUGAL (some say tight!).
I am a born and bred LOCAL - here to stay
I am CONTACTABLE - reach me through this website.
I know together WE CAN DO BETTER.

Tags

3 waters Campground casting vote cost of the dam council councillor role dam overruns Dean McNamara Debt decisions Dr Mike Joy Easter Trading Election fine print free lunch Funding inconsistencies lie Lies Mandates McKee Memorial Reserve performance Pigeon Valley Fire rate affordability Rate increase rates Richmond risks rules Shane Jones spending stormwater strategic misrepresentation Tasman Tasman council elections Tasman District Council tdc TDC propaganda vote Waimea Community Dam Waimea dam waimea irrigators water water bylaw WIL

Copyright © 2025 · TDCME.nz · Powered by Nz Marketing Systems · Log in

This website is authorized by Dean McNamara 22a Edward Street Wakefield