TDC Me

Your Say

Together we can achieve more

  • Home
  • Inclusive Council
  • Environment
  • Water
  • Housing
  • Business
  • Transport
  • Dam
  • Contact
  • About
    • Testimonials

Waimea Dam

12/08/2019

Share the message

waimea dam

I often get asked what my position on the Waimea Dam is.

When we were first presented with a model for the Waimea Dam I voted in favour. At that point it was more-or-less a user-pays funding model. As time progressed the funding model shifted to a public subsidisation of what is largely a private irrigation scheme. Not only in the construction costs but also in the forever ongoing running costs (ratepayer responsible for 51% of running costs) As it moved increasingly in that direction, I felt that I could no longer support the funding model.

However, it was not only the funding model that I have concerns over. I was unable to get satisfactory answers to questions I had about the longevity of the dam in relation to the rate of sediment build-up in the reservoir. If we are selling this dam as a 100 year plus solution to our water needs, then I would like to know that it will indeed have 100 years of capacity. I do not have that security of understanding from the information presented to me (or lack thereof).

Another concern is the budget allocated to certain aspects of the construction. I have experience in earthmoving so have some understanding of the mammoth task involved in operations such as clearing the reservoir of vegetation, putting in roads in unstable terrain, and complying with runoff regulations. Without direct access to the contractors to allay my concerns in how they intend to overcome some of these issues, I am suspicious of the amounts allowed for in the current budget.

Waimea Dam P95 guarantee
It can’t possibly go over $83 million dollars we have a P95

Other details we are assured are not an issue such as the lack of bedrock and reservoir wall stability do not line up with anecdotal evidence. The fact that no scientific study has been conducted into the path of the water into the aquifers nor the capacity of flow into the aquifers does not inspire confidence that releasing water into the river is going to solve the over allocation of pumping from the aquifers either. Nor was the fact that I was unable to get decommissioning cost allocation inserted into the Term Sheets, leaving future ratepayers exposed to the entire cost of the dam clean up at some point in the future.

Finally, I found it absurd that the irrigators were in-charge of the dam office during the stages of contractor procurement and final design of the dam when the irrigators had a capped contribution funding model. Whether they are corrupt or not, this situation leaves open a lot of room for accusation should it come to light that the budget is insufficient. It is thrust further into murky waters when Councillors were ruled ineligible for dam directorships (because of conflicted interests) but irrigators were appointed directors (surely a far greater conflict?).

The result of all this left me in a position where I could not support the current model of the Waimea Dam. I think it carries too much risk burden for the benefit to the ratepayer.

However, moving forward it is important to ensure that any cost overruns are not just borne by ratepayers and we make the most of the deal that has been dealt.  The Waimea Dam could be an asset to the Tasman region but the loading of dam related expenses onto the general ratepayer must stop. The ones benefiting the most need to be the ones paying the most.


Share the message

Filed Under: Dam Tagged With: Dean McNamara, Waimea dam

Introducing Dean

Dean McNamara Husband, father, and a fourth generation local from rural Tasman. Now acting as your voice on the Tasman District Council (TDC). More about me.

Email Newsletter

Sign up to be informed of important news and upcoming events

Make your voice count

Testimonials

Fantastic Speech

It was great to have your involvement in the dawn blessing of the Mapua Sculpture at the beginning of March. Thank you for the fantastic speech which encapsulated the essence of what the Sculpture Project is all about.

Janet Taylor
Ruby Coast Initiative Trust

You Rock

[Thankyou] for standing up for democracy & the people you represent. In the words of a younger generation “You Rock”!

Beth McCarthy
Takaka

keep sticking it to them

What a great pity there aren’t more councilors like yourself, who stand for council on behalf of the voters, and who remain steadfast in their commitment to being voter representatives and not council mouthpieces

Gary Thorpe
Read more testimonials
  • Testimonial Submission Form

Councillor McNamara: As Reported In The News

  • Latest News
    • Yet Another Unbudgeted Spend
    • Dam Tax Bites Little Guys
    • Freedom Camping Waste
    • No Support For Dam Report
    • Developing Within Boxes
    • Grandstand Funding Folly
    • Population Projections
    • Recycling Lunacy
    • Another Dam Blow Out
    • Councillors Not Qualified Directors
    • Mapua Boat Ramp
    • Pokies Sinking Lid Policy
    • No More Mayoral Casting Vote
    • Votes By Ward
    • Returning as Councillor
  • News From Last Term
    • Signing Off
    • Waste (of) money
    • Port Tarakohe
    • Free Charging Not Free
    • Re Election Candidates
    • NZTA Priorities
    • Mapua Upgrade Begins
    • Another vote Uturn
    • Traffic Woes Government Nos
    • Consult Fairy Tales
    • Capital Stop-Works
    • Kempthorne Quits
    • 20 million not a significant change
    • Over paid Councillor
    • Dam Train Wreck
    • Death Vote For Dam
    • Dam Scarce Water
    • Barbershop Gossip
    • Dam budget blowout
    • Dam Secrets
    • Wakefield Water Supply
    • Kempthorne Casting Votes
    • Mapua Gateway Sculpture
    • Mayor Spends Up Again
    • Mayor has a talk
    • Alleged Propaganda
    • Dam Affodability Questioned
    • Dam Funding Questions
    • Dam Questions
    • Storm Water Priorities
    • Knitting up a storm
    • Old guard take on new committee roles at Tasman District Council

Archives

Share the joy

Why Vote McNamara?

I am MOTIVATED.
I have business EXPERIENCE.
I am fiscally FRUGAL (some say tight!).
I am a born and bred LOCAL - here to stay
I am CONTACTABLE - reach me through this website.
I know together WE CAN DO BETTER.

Tags

budget blowout casting vote cost of the dam council councillor role dam budget dam overruns Dean McNamara Debt decisions Dr Mike Joy Easter Trading fine print free lunch Funding Governance inconsistencies Lies McKee Memorial Reserve P95 performance Pigeon Valley Fire rate affordability Rate increase rates Richard Kempthorne Richmond risks rules scaremongering mayor spending stormwater strategic misrepresentation Takaka grandstand Tasman Tasman District Council tdc TDC propaganda vote vote for change Waimea Community Dam Waimea dam waimea irrigators water water bylaw

Copyright © 2022 · TDCME.nz · Powered by Nz Marketing Systems · Log in

This website is authorized by Dean McNamara 22a Edward Street Wakefield